Boozy Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream

It's Pumpkin Season - Homemade Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream | @Susan Salzman | www.theurbanbaker.comIt’s October. Pumpkins are EVERYWHERE! It is just starting to cool down in L.A. and the flavors of fall are creeping into my home. Meals like Shepherds Pie, Claire’s Brisket, Butternut Squash Soup, Lasagna, and Chili are cooking in my kitchen. Making pumpkin soup is a weekly request. With left over pumpkin puree I am always finding ways of using up the left over puree.

The usual suspects; pumpkin cheesecake, pumpkin doughnuts, and now pumpkin ice cream. Having a few egg yolks in the fridge always ingnites my desire to make ice cream. I have to admit, I have become a little bored with our old favorites (butterscotch pecan, coffee cookie dough, sweet cream). Don’t get me wrong, they are good, better than good. But I wanted a new flavor and with this being fall, all I can think about is pumpkin. So glad I did. While the custard was cooking on the stove, it smelled just like fall. The smells of cinnamon and nutmeg infused my house.

It was so overwhelming that I couldnt help myself, I did stick my finger in the warm custard, before putting it into the ice cream machine. I was tempted to drink it. Really tempted. But didn’t.

Prescooped Homemade Pumpkin Ice Cream | @Susan Salzman | www.theurbanbaker.comI make quite a bit of ice cream and once the ice cream is made and put in the freezer safe container, it gets really, really frozen. Thus, scooping it becomes a workout. I decided to treat my ice cream like I do my cookie doughs. After it froze for about and hour and a half, using a 2 tablespoon ice cream scooper, I created little scoops and froze them on a parchement lined cookie sheet. Brilliant. In doing so, I was able to create so many wonderful treats. So many that I will be sharing them throughout the remainder of October.

Homemade Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream Bon Bons | @Susan Salzman | www.theurbanbaker.comOne of those ideas was Bon Bons. The idea came to me as I scooping the little balls onto the parchment lined baking sheets. Who doesn’t like a bon bon? I love the idea of a soft, creamy ice cream incrusted in a crispy, hard outer shell. Really good bittersweet chocolate, tempered, and drizzled over pumpkin ice cream. Heaven. I found that there truly is nothing better than chocolate + pumpkin. Such a great combo.

My ice cream maker and this recipe makes one quart of ice cream. Having individual ice cream balls on hand felt like I had way more than a quart of ice cream in my freezer. With so many on hand, I was able to deliver bon bons to a few of those that I adore.


Boozy Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream


12 ounces | 375 ml | 1 1/2 cups whole, organic milk
8 ounces | 250 ml | 1 cup organic, heavy cream
3 3/8 ounces | 95 grams | 1/3 cup plus 2 tablespoons maple sugar
1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1 cinnamon stick
1/4 teaspoon nutmeg
1/4 teaspoon Celtic sea salt
5 large egg yolks
2 ounces | 60 grams | 1/4 cup muscovado sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 tablespoon Markers Mark Bourbon
6 1/2 ounces | 180 grams | 3/4 cup organic, canned pumpkin puree


• in a small bowl, whisk the egg yolks and set aside.
• in a heavy duty saucepan, mix milk, cream, maple sugar, ground cinnamon, cinnamon stick, nutmeg, and salt.
• warm the mixture until warm and little bubbles form around the edge of the pan.
• in 1/4 cup batches, ladle half of the warm milk mixture into the egg yolks. whisking the whole time, after each addition of milk to avoid “cooking the egg yolks”. pour egg/milk mixture back into original saucepan(with half of the milk mixture that was not combined with the eggs) and cook over low heat.
• using a heat proof spatula, constantly stir custard mixture until it coats the back of a spatula (if you run your finger over the back of the spatula and a solid line remains from your finger, it’s ready) or until an instant-read thermometer reads 160- 170*.
• place a glass bowl inside a larger glass bowl filled with ice (you are creating an ice bath). place a strainer over the smaller glass bowl.
• pour custard mixture through the strainer. remove strainer and mix in the muscovado sugar. stir completely and let mixture cool.
• remove bowl from water bath and cover with plastic wrap. chill in fridge overnight.
• whisk in vanilla and bourbon (optional). place strainer over bowl of custard and press pumpkin puree throught the strainer. mix thoroughly.
• freeze custard in your ice cream maker (about 30 minutes), according the manufactureres instructions.
• place ice cream into a freezer safe container and freeze for at least 3 – 4 hours before eating.
note: after 1 1/2 hours, I scooped my ice cream into 1 1/2″ balls and froze on a rimmed baking sheet. when completely frozen I stored in a freezer safe container.

The Urban Baker /

More Pumpkin Recipes around the Web:

Pumpkin Pie Shake – Deliciously Organic
Pumpkin Thyme Mac and Cheese – Spoon Fork and Bacon
Pumpkin Muffins – Bakers Royale
Pumpkin Spice Donuts with Cinnamon Butter Glaze – Roost
White Mocha Frappuccino – Eat the Love

Showing 18 comments
  • Cathy @ Noble Pig

    Oh how lovely. And I love the sea salt. I used turbinado sugar in my pumpkin ice cream but the salt has me thinking! Tahnk you.

    • Susan

      Hi Cathy! I added the salt to cut back a bit on the sweetness of the two sugars. Everything needs a bit of salt. Don’t you agree?

  • Reply

    I love everything about this post. The talk of Fall flavors, links to other seasonal receipes and turning pumpkin ice cream into bon bons! Hello, amaaazing!

    • Susan

      Yes, Allison, bon bons were a win, win for everyone in my household!

  • Reply

    Thank you so much for reminding me of that way of freezing individual portions! And I totally love the bon bon idea, but I’d have a hard time giving any of those away.

    • Susan

      Hi Loretta, had I not given away the bon bons – I would have eaten them all. Way too dangerous for me to have in the house. Thank goodness for my 3 boys – they tend to eat my goodies as fast as it comes out of the kitchen!

  • Reply

    Those little bon bons look amazing! I can’t wait to see what you do with the rest of your ice cream. It’s such a great idea to freeze scoops that way!

    • Susan

      Hi Barb! Thanks so much. I think having little bites of ice cream is my new obsession. However, it’s way too easy to eat it!

  • marla

    Love that boozy twist ~ a fall celebration ice cream 🙂

  • Madonna

    I came back to your site to re-check the ingredients for the coffee ice cream. (I am not tired of it, in fact it is my new favorite.) I love the cookie scoop and bon bon idea. I have begun to put a little booze in my ice cream; I was told it keeps it from getting icy. I was wondering why you use more yolks with this recipe as opposed the the coffee one.

  • Esi

    Not only does this ice cream sound amazing, but I love all the pictures too!

    • Susan

      Thanks, Esi! Missing you!!!!

  • Laura Dembowski

    Pumpkin ice cream is my favorite. Adding booze probably makes it irresistible. I want a bowl right now.

    • Susan

      I have to admit, Laura – this ice cream disappeard very, very fast. When I first told the kids I was making pumpkin ice cream, they stuck their noses up in the air. They changed their tune upon first taste!

pingbacks / trackbacks
  • […] lots of individual, little balls of homemade boozy pumpkin pie ice cream on hand, this is exactly how we initially consumed them. Filling the cups with two scoops of ice […]

  • […] making the second batch, I hid a few in the freezer – right next to the pre-scooped pumpkin spice ice cream. An idea was born. The scoops of ice cream were the perfect size for these particular cookies. With […]

  • […] Thursday 11/28/13 – Happy Thanksgiving! Persimmon Mojito Honey Roasted Walnuts Shaved Brussel Sprout Salad Puree of Pumpkin Soup Turkey Rustic Herb Stuffing  Cranberry Relish   Corn Pudding Souffle  Mini Pecan Tassies  Boozy Pumpkin Ice Cream  […]

  • […] Boozy Pumpkin Pie Ice Cream from Urban Baker […]

Leave a Comment

Homemade Baked Granola Bars #glutenfree are a household favorite treat | @Susan Salzman | www.theurbanbaker.comSo many recipes to create with California Walnuts | @Susan Salzman |